Hurl vs HTTPie

Hurl vs HTTPie: compare their workflows, configuration choices, and practical tradeoffs.

Updated

short verdict

Use HTTPie while constructing and inspecting requests. Move repeatable checks into Hurl files with assertions when you need a recorded expected response.

An exploratory request and a repeatable API check have different maintenance needs. Keep successful experiments understandable when turning them into a team workflow.

this page is for

  • repeatable HTTP request tests
  • interactive HTTP requests and response inspection
pick

Hurl

★ 19.3kRust
details

Use Hurl for HTTP request files with response assertions, captured values, and CI reports.

best for

  • repeatable HTTP request tests

strengths

  • Chain requests and reuse captured response values
  • Assert on status, headers, XPath, JSONPath, or response body checks
  • Use --test and text, JUnit, TAP, HTML, or JSON reports

weaknesses

  • A maintained test suite needs request files and assertions updated when the API contract changes.
pick

HTTPie

★ 38.7kPython
details

Use HTTPie to build requests at the prompt, inspect formatted responses, and reuse persistent sessions.

best for

  • interactive HTTP requests and response inspection

strengths

  • Send JSON, forms, file uploads, custom methods, and headers
  • Inspect a constructed request in offline mode without sending it
  • Maintain request state with persistent sessions

weaknesses

  • Persistent sessions retain request state, so separate sessions when switching accounts or environments.

Key differences

  • Request definition: Hurl stores requests in plain-text files; HTTPie builds requests through the http and https commands.
  • Repeated state: Hurl captures response values for later requests; HTTPie provides persistent request sessions.
  • Inspection: Hurl evaluates response assertions; HTTPie formats responses and offers offline request construction.
  • Team workflow: Hurl emits test reports such as JUnit and HTML; HTTPie supports interactive API exploration with JSON, forms, and uploads.

Choose Hurl when

  • Chain requests and reuse captured response values
  • Assert on status, headers, XPath, JSONPath, or response body checks
  • Use --test and text, JUnit, TAP, HTML, or JSON reports

Choose HTTPie when

  • Send JSON, forms, file uploads, custom methods, and headers
  • Inspect a constructed request in offline mode without sending it
  • Maintain request state with persistent sessions

FAQ

How can one Hurl request use a value from an earlier response?
Capture the value from a response, then reference it in a later request in the file. This supports sequences such as obtaining a token before submitting a subsequent request.
Can I inspect an HTTPie request without sending it?
HTTPie has an offline mode for building and inspecting a request. Use it when you want to review the method, headers, or body before contacting the service.
What makes a Hurl file useful in CI?
Response assertions record the expected status, headers, or body, while --test selects test-oriented output. Reports can be emitted in formats including JUnit, TAP, HTML, and JSON.

related